Every question ends up with the owner. A capable engineer is promoted to supervisor and carries on doing the work rather than helping others do it. Feedback arrives only when something has gone wrong. A coaching culture is a way of working in which managers routinely use coaching conversations to help people improve their own performance, instead of relying on instruction alone.
In a small organisation, where knowledge can sit with a handful of managers, that shift can affect whether the business grows beyond what one or two people can oversee. This guide explains what a coaching culture is, how it differs from mentoring and managing, what the evidence says, and how a business with a small management team can build one without a training department.
What is a coaching culture?
A coaching culture makes coaching part of everyday management for everyone, not an occasional programme for a chosen few. Managers ask before they tell, people are expected to work out their own solutions, and progress is reviewed in regular one-to-one conversations.
The CIPD coaching and mentoring factsheet describes coaching and mentoring as development approaches based on one-to-one conversations that aim to improve a person’s skills, knowledge or work performance. It sets out generally agreed principles of coaching in organisations: coaching is essentially non-directive, the emphasis is on performance at work, it serves both organisational and individual goals, and it is a skilled activity that should be delivered by people trained in coaching skills.
The International Coaching Federation (ICF) and the Human Capital Institute (HCI) have run Building a Coaching Culture research since 2014; their most recent study surveyed 470 professionals from human resources, learning and development, and talent management. Their framework counts an organisation as having a strong coaching culture when it meets at least five of six components: employees value coaching; senior executives value coaching; managers, leaders or internal coaches have received accredited coach-specific training; internal coaches, external coaches and managers using coaching skills are all present; coaching has its own budget line; and all employees have an equal opportunity to receive coaching from a professional coach. The ICF page does not break respondents down by country, so the framework is not a UK benchmark, and several components, such as internal coach practitioners and a dedicated budget, assume a scale that a business of 20 or 50 people may not have. The first two components, and accredited coach-specific training for managers, can apply in a business of any size.
What is the difference between coaching, mentoring and managing?
Coaching helps a person find their own way to improve at a specific skill or goal, mentoring passes on an experienced colleague’s knowledge over a longer period, and managing includes direct instruction where the answer is fixed. A coaching culture uses all three, choosing coaching where the person can work out the answer.
The CIPD factsheet describes mentoring as a relationship in which a more experienced colleague shares their greater knowledge to support the development of someone less experienced, and notes that mentoring relationships tend to last longer than coaching arrangements. The CIPD notes that the two terms are often used interchangeably. Three approaches compare as follows:
| Coaching | Mentoring | Instructing (part of managing) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main aim | Improve performance on a specific skill or goal | Pass on experience and support longer-term development | Get a task done the right way |
| Who has the answer | Mostly the person being coached | Often the mentor | The manager or the procedure |
| Typical length | A defined period, or an ongoing management style | Longer term | One conversation |
| Small-business example | A supervisor working out how to brief a new starter | An experienced office manager guiding a newly promoted coordinator | Showing the right way to log a job in the system |
Instruction still has its place. A new starter learning the job system or a fixed procedure needs to be shown. The CIPD factsheet is clear that coaching is one of several development methods and is not the answer to every development need.
Why does a coaching culture matter in a small organisation?
A coaching culture matters in a small organisation because managers can be promoted for their technical skill and given little help with the people side of the role. Coaching gives them a practical way to develop their teams, and can help problems be solved closer to the work instead of being passed up to the owner.
The Chartered Management Institute’s 2023 research with YouGov, based on surveys of more than 4,500 UK workers and managers, found that 82% of people entering management positions had not had any formal management and leadership training. The CMI calls them “accidental managers”. The release does not break the figure down by employer size, so it is not specific to small businesses. Why strong technicians do not always become strong managers is covered in effective leadership behaviours that support business performance.
Two peer-reviewed meta-analyses give the evidence for coaching itself:
- Theeboom, Beersma and van Vianen (2014). This meta-analysis in The Journal of Positive Psychology found that coaching in organisations had significant positive effects on all five individual outcomes it examined: performance and skills, well-being, coping, work attitudes, and goal-directed self-regulation.
- Jones, Woods and Guillaume (2016). This meta-analysis of 17 studies in the Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology found that workplace coaching had a positive overall effect on organisational outcomes, with larger effects when the coach was internal (an employee in a coaching role) rather than external.
Jones and colleagues looked only at coaching by internal or external coaches and excluded coaching by a person’s own line manager or by peers, so their results do not show how well managers coaching their own teams works. Neither meta-analysis is specific to small businesses or to contracting.
Rostone Operating Partners sees founder-led contracting businesses where the owner has become the person everyone goes to for answers, and the habit is reinforced each time the owner simply gives one. A coaching approach does not stop the owner helping; it changes the help from answering the question to asking what the person thinks and what they would try first.
Rostone looks at a coaching culture through the four GRAX options: Grow, Raise, Acquire and Exit. To grow, coaching can help managers take on more without each decision returning to the owner. To raise finance, it can show a lender a management team, not one person. To acquire, it gives a way to bring a new team’s managers into shared habits. To exit, it supports business succession planning, because a buyer or successor is likely to look for people ready to step up. Over time, coaching becomes part of the wider organisational development of the business.
What does a coaching culture look like day to day?
A coaching culture looks like regular one-to-one conversations, managers who ask questions before giving answers, short reviews after work goes well or badly, and agreed actions that are followed up. Coaching becomes part of normal management rather than a separate activity booked in a training room. Those conversations also draw on the skills covered in the guide on how to improve emotional intelligence, such as listening before answering and staying calm when feedback is hard to hear.
Acas guidance on performance management says managers should talk to employees informally about their performance on a regular basis, and lists sharing regular feedback, coaching and regular check-ins, sometimes called one-to-ones, among the informal methods. The CIPD factsheet notes that organisations typically apply coaching as a day-to-day management activity, embedded into one-to-one meetings and performance conversations.
Four habits put coaching into daily work: one-to-ones, questions before answers, short reviews and written actions.
- One-to-ones. A short, regular conversation between each manager and each team member, at a set time, that covers progress, problems and development, not only the latest job.
- Questions before answers. When someone brings a problem, the manager first asks what they think is happening and what they would do, then adds their own view.
- Short reviews. After a difficult week, a lost quote or a smooth handover, the team spends ten minutes on what worked, what did not and what to change.
- Written actions. Each conversation ends with one or two actions, an owner and a date, which are checked at the next one-to-one.
Coaching sits alongside the other parts of a healthy working environment, such as trust, shared values and recognition, which are covered in ways to create a healthy company culture. A shared purpose can give those values a reference point; what a purpose-driven business is explains how a purpose beyond profit can guide everyday decisions.
How do you create a coaching culture in a small organisation?
A small organisation can create a coaching culture by starting with the owner’s own behaviour, training managers in basic coaching skills, building coaching into meetings that already happen, making it safe to raise problems, and reviewing how the approach is working.
Six steps cover the ground: start from the business’s priorities and lead from the top, train managers, choose one model, build it into existing meetings, make it safe to raise problems and support the coaches.
- Start from the business’s priorities and lead from the top. The owner and senior managers coach their own direct reports and ask for feedback on their own work. The CIPD factsheet suggests starting from the organisation’s strategy and priorities and who will support coaching before deciding how it is delivered.
- Train managers in coaching skills. A short course in listening, questioning and agreeing actions can give managers a common approach. The wider leadership qualities a development programme can build are covered separately.
- Choose one simple model. A shared structure such as GROW, explained below, gives every manager the same steps and the team a familiar pattern.
- Build it into existing meetings. Use the weekly one-to-one, the job review and the team meeting rather than adding new sessions that are dropped when the diary fills up.
- Make it safe to raise problems. Amy Edmondson’s 1999 study of 51 work teams in a manufacturing company defined team psychological safety as a shared belief held by members of a team that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking. The study found that team psychological safety was associated with team learning behaviour, which in turn was linked to team performance.
- Support the coaches. The CIPD notes that coaching can be challenging for those doing it and that coaches need structured opportunities to reflect on their practice, alone or in groups. In a small business, that can be a monthly conversation between managers about what is and is not working.
Coaching is one of several activities that can sit within a wider plan for developing people, covered in how to create a learning and development strategy in an SME.
What is the GROW coaching model?
The GROW coaching model is a four-stage structure for a coaching conversation: Goal, Reality, Options and Will, sometimes called Way forward. It gives managers who are new to coaching a simple order to follow, from what the person wants to achieve to what they will do next.
Performance Consultants, the coaching firm Sir John Whitmore founded, says the model was developed by Whitmore with his peers in the late 1980s and early 1990s; it became widely known through his book Coaching for Performance. The CIPD factsheet names GROW among the models people professionals need to assess for relevance and credibility. The four stages of GROW are goal, reality, options and will:
- Goal. What does the person want to achieve? For example, a service coordinator in a Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC) business wants engineers to receive complete job information the day before each visit.
- Reality. What is happening now? Which details are missing, how often, and where in the process do they drop out?
- Options. What could be done? A booking checklist, a change to the job system, a call to the customer, or a question for the surveyor.
- Will. What will the person do, by when, and how will they know it has worked?
Performance Consultants quotes Whitmore’s warning that “any dictator can use GROW”, and says the framework should be used alongside coaching skills, with thoughtful, open questions at its centre.
What gets in the way of a coaching culture?
Obstacles to a coaching culture include the power gap between a manager and their own team, time pressure, coaching people who are not ready for it, and unclear rules on confidentiality. Each one can be planned for before coaching starts.
Four obstacles are worth naming: the manager-coach tension, time, readiness and confidentiality (the first, third and fourth are discussed in the CIPD factsheet).
- The manager-coach tension. The CIPD factsheet notes a common question about how effectively managers can coach their own staff, given the power relationship and the need for impartiality in coaching.
- Time. When the diary is full, telling feels quicker than asking. Short, regular conversations can be easier to protect than long, occasional ones.
- Readiness. The CIPD advises checking a person’s readiness and motivation before coaching starts, because some development needs are better met another way.
- Confidentiality. The CIPD recommends agreeing guidelines on confidentiality and how information flows, so people trust what they share.
People also hear the same feedback differently depending on how they prefer to communicate. How a team can talk about those differences without blame is covered in workplace communication skills and how DISC helps a team communicate clearly.
How can a small organisation tell whether its coaching culture is working?
A small organisation can check whether coaching habits are taking hold by tracking a few simple indicators: whether one-to-ones happen as planned, whether agreed actions are completed, whether fewer routine questions reach the owner, and what staff say about the support they receive.
Four indicators need no HR team: one-to-ones held against those planned, actions completed by the agreed date, routine decisions now made below the owner, and a short staff pulse question on development. The CIPD says the quality of coaching and its results depend in part on evaluating success. These indicators show whether the habits are in place rather than proving an effect on performance, and they can sit alongside the business’s other measures, as described in business performance management for a small business.
The DISC Team Assessments and Workshops service gives each person taking part, usually the owner and management team first, a personal DISC report and the team a shared map of working styles, followed by a facilitated workshop to agree practical changes to briefings, handovers and feedback.
Frequently asked questions
There is no fixed timescale for building a coaching culture. Regular one-to-ones and a shared coaching model can be in place within a few months, while the habit of asking before telling takes longer to settle. Tracking whether one-to-ones happen and actions are completed shows whether the habit is forming.
Coaching culture training for managers can cover listening, asking open questions, giving feedback and agreeing actions, built around a model such as GROW. The CIPD describes coaching as a skilled activity delivered by people trained in coaching skills, and the ICF and HCI framework counts accredited coach-specific training as one component of a strong coaching culture.
A coaching culture in a sales team uses the same habits as the rest of the business: regular one-to-ones, asking before telling and agreed actions. In a contracting business the sales role may sit with estimators, surveyors or the owner; reviewing real quotes and lost enquiries together gives the coaching a practical focus, with the salesperson working out what to change before the manager offers a view.
Internal coaches are employees trained to coach colleagues, while external coaches are independent practitioners brought in from outside. The CIPD notes that some organisations hire external coaches, particularly for very senior people, and that line managers are most likely to take the main responsibility for coaching inside organisations.
A good coaching question is open, short and puts the thinking with the other person, such as “What have you tried so far?” or “What would you do if I were not here?”. It avoids hidden advice, such as “Have you thought about calling the customer?”, which can be an instruction phrased as a question.
Sources
CIPD: Coaching and mentoring factsheet
Acas: Performance management
Chartered Management Institute: Bad managers and toxic work culture causing one in three staff to walk (2023)
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam Research Portal: Theeboom, Beersma and van Vianen (2014), Does coaching work? A meta-analysis
Aston University Research Explorer: Jones, Woods and Guillaume (2016), The effectiveness of workplace coaching: a meta-analysis
Harvard DASH: Edmondson (1999), Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams
International Coaching Federation: Building a Coaching Culture research
Performance Consultants: The GROW model
Last updated: 13 November 2026




