Teams take many of their cues from the person running them. How that person sets expectations, reacts to a mistake, hands out work and talks about the customer tends to be copied, quietly, by the people around them. Leadership behaviours are the things a manager repeatedly does and says that shape how a team works: how they set direction, make decisions, give feedback and respond to problems.
Because they are behaviours rather than fixed traits, they can be seen, discussed and improved. This guide sets out what leadership behaviours are, why they affect performance and staff retention, eight effective leadership behaviours with examples from project-based businesses, and how managers can build them into the way the business runs.
What are leadership behaviours?
Leadership behaviours are the observable actions a leader repeats, such as explaining decisions, following up on commitments and listening before deciding. They differ from traits, which describe what a person is like, and from skills, which describe what a person knows how to do. A confident person can still avoid difficult conversations; a quiet person can still set clear expectations every Monday.
That distinction matters because behaviours can be learned. Acas guidance on leadership, published in 2019, groups effective leadership into four areas: personal style, workplace culture, communication skills, and the big workplace issues such as absence, discipline and performance. It describes effective leaders as positive role models of behaviour who show trust in others through collaboration and delegation.
Some people find these behaviours come easily; others build them through practice, feedback and a deliberate learning and development strategy. A manager’s behaviours also shape whether the training, involvement and review practices of high performance work systems are used day to day.
Why do leadership behaviours matter for business performance?
Leadership behaviours matter for business performance because managers shape how engaged, productive and settled their teams are, and management practices are linked with productivity in UK firms. The manager is the point where plans become daily work.
Gallup, the US analytics and research company, estimated in 2014 that managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement scores across business units, in its article Why Great Managers Are So Rare. The analysis is based on Gallup’s own workplace studies rather than UK data, but the pattern it describes is familiar: two teams in the same business, with the same pay and systems, can perform very differently under different managers.
In the UK, the Office for National Statistics bulletin Management practices in the UK: 2016 to 2023 scores firms with 10 or more employees in the production and services industries on how they approach continuous improvement, use key performance indicators, set targets, and handle promotion, training and underperformance. It reports that productivity is statistically significantly related to higher management practice scores. That is a correlation rather than proof of cause, but several of the practices it measures, such as dealing with underperformance and how promotion is decided, depend directly on how managers behave.
How do leadership behaviours affect staff retention?
Leadership behaviours affect staff retention because many people who do not rate their manager plan to leave. In an HVAC, electrical contracting or renewables business that depends on skilled engineers, installers and supervisors, each departure takes knowledge, customer relationships and capacity with it.
Research by the Chartered Management Institute and YouGov, published in 2023 as Taking Responsibility: Why UK plc needs better managers, a survey of more than 4,500 UK workers and managers, found that of workers who do not rate their manager, half (50%) plan to leave their company in the next year. The same research found that one in three people, managers and workers alike, have left a job because of a negative work culture.
The CIPD Good Work Index 2026, a CIPD and YouGov survey of more than 5,000 UK employees, points the same way: employees with bad line management were more likely to say they would quit, and poor line management was linked with work harming mental health. Retention can look like a pay question, but these findings suggest the day-to-day behaviour of the line manager is part of the answer.
Why do good technicians not always make good managers?
Good technicians do not always make good managers because the behaviours that make someone excellent at the work are different from the behaviours needed to lead the people doing it. When promotion rewards technical skill or length of service, the new role then asks for a different set of behaviours.
The CMI research found that 82% of people entering management roles have had no formal management or leadership training, which it describes as “accidental managers”. Separately, Gallup’s 2014 analysis found that companies fail to choose the candidate with the right talent for manager roles 82% of the time, and that about one in 10 people have the talent to manage, with a further two in 10 showing some of the characteristics.
In Rostone Operating Partners’ work with project-based businesses, the step from best engineer to supervisor is where the gap shows. The new supervisor keeps fixing technical problems personally, because that is what earned the promotion, and the team learns to wait for them rather than solve problems themselves. The fix Rostone looks at first is a clear description of the new role and practice in the behaviours it needs.
What are eight effective leadership behaviours?
Eight effective leadership behaviours are: understanding what motivates each person, being assertive without being authoritarian, holding yourself and others accountable, being honest and transparent, being approachable, being objective and fair, being attentive to people’s needs and wellbeing, and leading by example. The grouping is this guide’s own; Acas’s framework covers fairness, honest communication, wellbeing and acting as a role model.
Understand what motivates each person
Effective leaders recognise that people are motivated by different things. One engineer wants the most complex jobs and the chance to learn; another values a predictable diary and regular feedback; a third wants a route into supervising. Pay matters, but on its own it does not explain why one team goes the extra mile and another does the minimum.
The practical behaviour is to ask, in one-to-ones, what each person wants from the next year, and then to use the answer when allocating work. Workplace personality tests can give a shared language for these differences, as long as they are used to understand people rather than to label them.
Be assertive without being authoritarian
Assertive leaders make decisions and stand behind them, especially when the situation is difficult. Being assertive is not the same as ignoring other views: it means listening to the people closest to the problem, deciding within a reasonable time, and explaining the reason.
A project manager who asks the site supervisor and the estimator for their view before agreeing a variation, then makes the call and tells the customer clearly, is being assertive. One who changes the decision each time a different person complains is not, and the team soon learns that the last voice wins.
Hold yourself and others accountable
Accountable leaders take responsibility when things go wrong in their area, rather than passing blame, and they expect the same from others. This can build trust and make it safer for people to raise problems early, when they are cheaper to fix.
Accountability is easier to see when it is attached to something measurable: a named owner, a date and a result. A short weekly review of a few numbers, as described in this guide to small business performance management, turns accountability from a personality trait into a routine. Writing those results as clear goals, using a goal setting framework such as SMART goals or OKRs, makes the weekly review easier to run.
Be honest and transparent
Honest and transparent leaders share the reasons behind decisions, give bad news early and do not promise what they cannot deliver. Difficult news given early can be easier for a team to deal with than surprises or rumours.
In practice, this means telling the team when a large contract has been lost and what it means for the next quarter, or telling a customer as soon as a delivery date slips rather than on the day it was due. Transparency also runs the other way: a leader who is open about their own mistakes makes it easier for others to admit theirs.
Be approachable
Approachable leaders make it easy for people to bring them problems, ideas and bad news. For some managers this comes naturally; for others it has to be practised, especially when they are busy or under pressure.
Simple behaviours help: asking open questions, listening to the end of the answer, being visible at the times people need decisions, and thanking people who raise problems rather than shooting the messenger. Teams communicate in different styles, and workplace communication skills such as adapting to how each person prefers to receive information make a manager easier to approach.
Be objective and fair
Objective leaders base decisions about work, pay, promotion and feedback on evidence rather than on who they like. Everyone has preferences; the behaviour is to notice them and decide on the facts anyway.
Acas guidance stresses treating everyone fairly and consistently, including when policies are followed, changed and communicated. In a field team, that might mean allocating overtime and the better jobs by a visible rule, and giving feedback on the work, with examples, rather than on the person.
Be attentive to people’s needs and wellbeing
Attentive leaders notice how the people in their team are doing, not only how the work is going. They spot when someone is overloaded, struggling or disengaged, and they ask before it becomes a resignation or a sickness absence. This draws on emotional intelligence, the ability to recognise and manage emotions in yourself and others.
The Health and Safety Executive links managing work-related stress to manager competencies. Its Management Standards guidance on work-related stress encourages employers to identify and develop the competencies managers need to manage sources of stress, and offers a line manager competency indicator tool to show where there are gaps in skills or behaviours.
Lead by example
Leaders who lead by example model the standards they expect. If the manager skips the weekly review, arrives late to the morning meeting or cuts corners on paperwork, the team takes that as the real standard, whatever the procedure says.
Leading by example also matters at the top of a business. In a family firm, the way the next generation behaves day to day affects whether the team accepts them, which is one reason leadership behaviours matter in business succession planning.
The table below summarises what each behaviour looks like day to day and the problem it helps to prevent.
| Behaviour | What it looks like day to day | What it helps to prevent |
|---|---|---|
| Understand motivations | Asking each person what they want and using it when allocating work | Disengagement and avoidable leavers |
| Assertive, not authoritarian | Listening, deciding within a set time, explaining why | Drifting decisions and the last voice winning |
| Accountable | Named owners, dates and a weekly check of results | Blame and problems hidden until they are expensive |
| Honest and transparent | Sharing reasons and bad news early | Rumours, surprises and lost trust |
| Approachable | Open questions, visible at decision times, thanking people who raise problems | Problems reported too late |
| Objective and fair | Work, overtime and feedback decided by visible rules and evidence | Perceived favouritism and grievances |
| Attentive | Noticing workload and wellbeing, and asking early | Burnout, absence and sudden resignations |
| Lead by example | Following the same standards the team is asked to follow | Procedures that exist on paper only |
How can managers develop leadership behaviours?
Managers can develop leadership behaviours by choosing a small number to work on, practising them in routines that already exist, and getting regular feedback on whether they are showing up. Two well-known models help to give that practice a structure.
The first is the Five Practices of Exemplary Leadership, developed by Jim Kouzes and Barry Posner from more than 40 years of research and set out in their book The Leadership Challenge. The five practices are model the way, inspire a shared vision, challenge the process, enable others to act and encourage the heart:
- Model the way. Do what you say you will do, and set the example for the standards you expect.
- Inspire a shared vision. Describe where the business is heading in a way the team can picture and want.
- Challenge the process. Look for better ways of working and encourage others to experiment, the habit at the heart of continuous improvement.
- Enable others to act. Build collaboration and give people the trust, skills and authority to act.
- Encourage the heart. Recognise contributions and celebrate progress.
The second is the Situational Leadership model, which the Center for Leadership Studies says Dr Paul Hersey developed in 1969. It holds that there is no one-size-fits-all style, and that leaders match their style to the person’s readiness for the task: their ability and willingness to do it. It sets out four styles: telling, selling, participating and delegating.
- Telling. High direction and low relationship behaviour: clear, specific instructions for someone not yet able or confident to do the task.
- Selling. High direction and high relationship behaviour: the leader still decides, but explains the reasons and builds commitment.
- Participating. Low direction and high relationship behaviour: the leader asks questions and supports, and the person increasingly decides.
- Delegating. Low direction and low relationship behaviour: the person works on their own, with the leader available if needed.
A new planner who is unsure of the scheduling system needs telling; an experienced estimator who has lost confidence after a pricing mistake may need participating; a contracts manager running their own accounts needs delegating. The same manager may use all four styles in one morning.
Rostone’s approach is to attach leadership behaviours to routines the business already runs, such as the weekly operations meeting, one-to-ones and job reviews, so they are practised every week rather than discussed once on a course. Coaching one-to-ones are one such routine, and how to create a coaching culture in a small organisation covers how managers can build the habit of asking before telling. Within the GRAX approach of Grow, Raise, Acquire and Exit, this is part of making a business less dependent on its owner: the aim is for decisions and standards to hold without the owner in the room.
How can a business check its leadership behaviours?
A business can check its leadership behaviours by asking the team, looking at the evidence the business already has, and watching how managers behave in everyday situations, then acting on what it finds. Four steps make up a simple check: ask the team, look at the evidence, watch everyday situations, and pick one or two behaviours to improve.
- Ask the team. A short, anonymous survey with a few questions, such as whether people know what is expected of them and whether they would raise a problem with their manager.
- Look at the evidence. Reasons given by leavers, absence patterns, and where rework and callbacks cluster can point to a team where leadership needs attention, alongside other causes such as workload or training.
- Watch everyday situations. How a manager runs the morning meeting, handles a complaint or responds to a mistake can show their behaviours more clearly than an interview.
- Pick one or two behaviours to improve. Agree them with each manager, attach them to a routine, and review progress monthly.
Behavioural models can help managers see how their own style comes across. A DISC team assessment maps how each person in a team prefers to work and communicate, giving managers and teams a shared, blame-free way to discuss those differences.
Frequently asked questions
A leadership style is a broad pattern, such as directive or delegating, while behaviours are the specific actions that make it up, such as explaining a decision or checking in after a handover. Models such as Situational Leadership suggest leaders switch style to suit the person and task. The behaviours in this guide apply whichever style a manager is using.
Leadership behaviours are learned through practice and feedback: a manager picks one or two behaviours, asks the team how they are coming across, and adjusts. A training course can introduce the ideas; practising them at work is what turns them into habits.
There is no single most important behaviour for every situation. Leading by example is a practical starting point, because teams tend to copy what the leader does, and the other behaviours can lose credibility without it.
Leadership behaviours affect employee retention because line managers shape how people experience their job day to day, including workload, feedback and fairness. UK surveys from the CMI (2023) and CIPD (2026) link poor line management with plans to leave, which makes manager behaviour part of any retention plan alongside pay.
Setting clear expectations, being approachable and holding people accountable are practical first steps. They help a new supervisor move from doing the work personally to helping the team do it, which is the main change the role asks for.
Sources
Acas: Leading people (2019)
Gallup: Why Great Managers Are So Rare
Office for National Statistics: Management practices in the UK: 2016 to 2023
Chartered Management Institute: Bad managers and toxic work culture causing one in three staff to walk
CIPD: Good Work Index 2026
Health and Safety Executive: Management Standards: what to do next
The Leadership Challenge: The Five Practices of Exemplary Leadership
Center for Leadership Studies: The four leadership styles of Situational Leadership
Last updated: 13 November 2026



