Picture the best engineer on the team being made supervisor. Six months later the jobs still run, but the supervisor is doing the hardest work personally, avoiding awkward conversations and phoning the owner about every decision. A leadership development programme is a planned set of training, practice and support that builds the skills people need to lead others, from a first team to a senior role.
This guide explains what a leadership development programme is, why it matters most for first-line managers promoted from the tools, what research says makes leadership training work, and 15 ideas for what a programme can include. It is written for heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC), electrical contracting and renewables businesses turning over £1M–£50M, where supervisors and contracts managers carry much of the day-to-day leadership.
What is a leadership development programme?
A leadership development programme runs over weeks or months and combines learning, practice on the job, feedback and support, so it follows the person back into the work rather than ending when a course does.
In a smaller business, a programme can be as simple as a short course, monthly coaching from a senior manager, and two or three real responsibilities handed over with support. Core people skills, such as listening, giving feedback and handling conflict, are common building blocks of a leadership development programme. A leadership programme can sit within a wider learning and development strategy that also covers technical training, apprenticeships and succession. Management development is also one of the interventions in organisational development, which looks at how people, teams and managers work together across the business.
Why do supervisors and contracts managers need a leadership development programme?
Supervisors and contracts managers need a leadership development programme because leading people is a different job from the technical work they were promoted from, and many start it untrained. UK research from the Chartered Management Institute (CMI) found that 82% of managers entering management roles had no formal management and leadership training. Supervisors are also the people who run reviews, agree training and respond to staff suggestions, which is why equipping them is one of the steps in how to develop high performance work practices in a contracting business.
The CMI’s Better Management Report: Take Responsibility, Take Action (October 2023), based on research with YouGov among more than 4,500 people working across the UK, calls these people “accidental managers”. The same report found that half of workers who rate their manager as ineffective are planning to leave their organisation in the next 12 months, compared with 21% of those who say their manager is effective.
The promotion route itself plays a part. A 2019 study in the Quarterly Journal of Economics, Promotions and the Peter Principle by Alan Benson, Danielle Li and Kelly Shue, used data on sales workers at 131 firms and found that firms prioritise current job performance in promotion decisions at the expense of other characteristics that better predict managerial performance. The study covers sales workers, not the trades, so it does not test contracting businesses directly; what it shows is the risk of promoting mainly on current performance.
Employees’ views of their managers leave room for improvement. The CIPD Good Work Index 2026 (July 2026), based on a survey of 5,074 UK employees, found that 57% of employees with a line manager agree their manager supports their learning and development, and that fewer than six in 10 agree their manager provides useful feedback on their work.
A pattern Rostone Operating Partners sees in contracting businesses is a newly promoted supervisor who keeps taking the hardest jobs personally and passes people problems up to the owner, because nobody has defined what the new role is for or given the supervisor the skills to do it.
What does research say makes leadership training work?
Research says leadership training works better when it starts from a needs analysis, includes practice and feedback, uses more than one delivery method and is spread over several sessions. A 2017 meta-analysis of 335 independent samples found leadership training to be substantially more effective than previously thought.
The meta-analysis, Leadership training design, delivery, and implementation by Christina Lacerenza and colleagues in the Journal of Applied Psychology (2017), measured effects on four outcomes: reactions, learning, transfer to the job and results. Its findings supported six design features:
- Needs analysis. Deciding what to train based on what the role and the person need.
- Feedback. Telling participants how they are doing during the programme.
- Multiple delivery methods. Combining information, demonstration and, especially, practice.
- Spaced sessions. Spreading training over time rather than one block.
- On-site delivery. Training held at the participant’s place of work.
- Face-to-face delivery. Training that is not self-administered.
For a contracting business, the practical reading is that a single course on its own cannot use spaced sessions, one of the features the research supports. Short sessions spread over months, each followed by a real task back at work and a conversation about how it went, add spacing, practice and feedback to the programme.
What should a leadership development programme include for first-line managers?
A leadership development programme for first-line managers should include skills for leading people, skills for running the work and skills for growing as a leader. Fifteen ideas follow, grouped in those three areas, and a business can pick the ones that match the gaps it sees. The day-to-day routines these skills support, such as one-to-ones, clear decision rights and weekly measures, are covered in how leaders can improve productivity in a contracting business.
Ideas for leading people
Five ideas for leading people are one-to-ones, feedback, coaching, early conflict conversations and team culture:
- Hold regular one-to-ones. A short, scheduled conversation with each team member about work, problems and development gives a new supervisor a habit to build on.
- Give useful feedback. Practise saying what went well and what needs to change, specifically and soon after the event.
- Coach rather than fix. Ask questions that help an engineer solve a problem instead of taking it over; how to build that habit is covered in how to create a coaching culture in a small organisation.
- Have the early conversation. Independent research for Acas, Managing conflict at work (University of Westminster and University of Sheffield, 2024), found that line managers were not always given the skills and support to resolve conflict early, that formal training was patchy, and that newer managers were less confident about having early, informal conversations. The study covered seven organisations of 150 or more employees and no SMEs, so its findings may not transfer directly to smaller firms, though early conversations are part of a supervisor’s role at any size.
- Shape the team’s culture. Supervisors influence what a team treats as acceptable through what they notice, praise and let pass; ways to build a positive culture are set out in how to create a healthy company culture.
Ideas for running the work
Five ideas for running the work are planning, using numbers, decision rights, safety leadership and handovers:
- Plan and allocate the team’s week. Teach how labour, vans and materials are planned, and how to replan when a job overruns.
- Use a few numbers. The Office for National Statistics bulletin Management practices in the UK: 2016 to 2023 (May 2024) found that in 2023 firms with below-median management scores were four times more likely than firms above the median to use little to no analysis to support business decisions. A supervisor who understands labour hours, overtime and job margin is better placed to make informed calls.
- Know which decisions are theirs. Write down what a supervisor or contracts manager can approve, such as overtime, small purchases or a change to the schedule, and what still goes up.
- Lead on health and safety. The CITB Site Supervision Safety Training Scheme (SSSTS) is a two-day course for those who have, or are about to have, supervisory responsibilities; its aims centre on health, safety and welfare, the relevant legislation, risk assessments and method statements, and supervising high-risk work, so it complements rather than replaces wider people management training.
- Run short meetings and clean handovers. Practise a 10-minute team briefing and a written handover so information does not depend on one person’s memory.
Ideas for growing as a leader
Five ideas for growing as a leader are self-awareness, emotional intelligence, leading by example, moving from doing to leading, and resilience:
- Build self-awareness. Behavioural profiles can show a new leader how their style comes across; the main tools are compared in how to use workplace personality tests.
- Develop emotional intelligence. Practical ways to notice and manage reactions under pressure are set out in how to improve emotional intelligence.
- Lead by example. Keeping commitments, owning mistakes and treating people consistently are examples of the effective leadership behaviours a team sees every day.
- Move from doing to leading. Agree how much hands-on work the role includes, so the supervisor has time to plan, check and support the team.
- Manage pressure and wellbeing. Cover how to spot stress in the team and in oneself, and where to get support.
How can a smaller business deliver a leadership development programme?
A smaller business can deliver a leadership development programme by combining in-house coaching and real responsibilities with a short external course or qualification. Options range from internal mentoring to accredited qualifications and apprenticeships, and each comes with different costs, time commitments and eligibility rules.
The ONS management practices bulletin found that 89% of firms surveyed in 2023 reported taking some action to improve management quality; of those firms, 43% carried out formal training online and 42% in person. The 2023 survey covered UK firms with 10 or more employees in the production and services industries, excluding agriculture, financial services and the public sector. Five delivery routes are compared below: internal coaching, short accredited qualifications, apprenticeships, safety supervision courses and programmes for owners:
| Route | What it involves | Points to check |
|---|---|---|
| Internal coaching and mentoring | A senior manager meets the new leader regularly and reviews real tasks | Needs protected time and a coach with the right skills |
| Accredited qualification | For example, the Level 3 Leadership and Management Skills qualifications from ILM, part of City & Guilds, with an Award of 40 guided learning hours and a Certificate of 80 | Assessed by portfolio; check what a centre charges |
| Apprenticeship | The Team leader (Level 3) and Operations manager (Level 5) apprenticeship standards on Skills England | In England, not government funded for new starts from 1 September 2026; still available privately funded. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland run their own apprenticeship schemes |
| Safety supervision course | CITB SSSTS for people taking on supervisory responsibilities | Focused on health and safety duties, not wider people management |
| Programme for owners and directors | Help to Grow: Management, government-funded training for SME business leaders | £750 joining fee; UK businesses with 5–249 employees operating for more than a year; charities not eligible; check full criteria |
The apprenticeship change is recent and applies to apprenticeships in England. The GOV.UK Growth and Skills Levy reforms factsheet (September 2026) lists Team Leader at Level 3 and Operations Manager at Level 5 among 16 standards losing funding for all new starts from September 2026, with existing apprentices funded to completion. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have their own apprenticeship schemes and funding rules. Funding rules change, so check the current position before planning around an apprenticeship.
How is a leadership development programme measured?
A leadership development programme is commonly measured at four levels: how participants react, what they learn, whether they use it at work and what changes in results. The Lacerenza meta-analysis used these four outcomes, and the third and fourth are closest to what a business owner wants to see change.
Four kinds of measure fit those levels:
- Reaction. A short feedback form after each session.
- Learning. A practical check, such as running a mock one-to-one or reading a job cost report.
- Transfer. Whether one-to-ones are happening, handovers are written and the supervisor deals with issues before they reach the owner.
- Results. Team turnover, absence, overtime and job margin compared with the period before the programme, bearing in mind that other factors also move these figures.
Rostone uses a simple check for transfer: list the decisions that came to the owner in a week and mark which ones a supervisor or contracts manager could have made with clearer authority and the right skills. Repeating the list a few months into a programme can indicate whether decisions are moving down the business.
How does leadership development affect growth and exit?
Leadership development affects growth and exit because a business that depends on the owner for most decisions has less capacity to grow, and buyers and investors look at how far a business relies on its owner. Developing supervisors and contracts managers spreads decisions across a team and gives a buyer or investor a management layer to assess.
Rostone looks at leadership depth through the four GRAX options: Grow, Raise, Acquire and Exit. To grow, the business needs leaders who can run more teams without the owner in every conversation. To raise finance, it needs a management team that can show it can deliver the plan the money is for; to acquire another firm, it needs managers who can take on new people and processes. For an exit, the question is whether the business can run without the owner, which is where leadership development meets succession planning.
Where working styles are part of the gap, the DISC team assessments and workshops page explains how an individual DISC report for each person, a team map and a facilitated workshop help a leadership or management team understand how its members prefer to work, communicate and make decisions.
Frequently asked questions
Management development focuses on running the work: planning, budgets, procedures and reporting. Leadership development focuses on leading people: setting direction, giving feedback, coaching and handling conflict. A first-line manager needs both, so a programme for supervisors can combine them.
A small business example is a six-month programme for new supervisors: a short accredited course, monthly coaching from a senior manager, and three responsibilities handed over in turn, such as weekly planning, one-to-ones and approving overtime. Each step is reviewed in a short conversation about what worked and what to change.
A leadership development programme can run over months rather than days, because research on leadership training supports spaced sessions with practice between them. Accredited qualifications vary in size; the ILM Level 3 Leadership and Management Skills Award, for example, involves 40 guided learning hours.
Qualifications for new supervisors in the UK include the Level 3 Leadership and Management Skills qualifications from ILM, part of City & Guilds, and, in England, the Team leader apprenticeship standard at Level 3. From 1 September 2026, new starts on the Team leader apprenticeship in England are not government funded, although it remains available to privately funded apprentices; Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland run their own apprenticeship schemes. In construction-related work, the CITB SSSTS course covers health and safety duties for supervisors.
A business sets a baseline by recording, before the programme starts, the figures it expects the programme to change. A baseline taken before the programme, such as how many decisions reach the owner each week, how often one-to-ones happen and team turnover, gives later checks something to compare against. Changes in results should be read alongside other factors, such as workload and staffing, that move the same figures.
Sources
Acas: Managing conflict at work: policy, procedure and informal resolution (independent research, 2024)
Chartered Management Institute: Better Management Report: Take Responsibility, Take Action (2023)
CIPD: CIPD Good Work Index 2026
CITB: Site Supervision Safety Training Scheme (SSSTS)
City & Guilds (ILM): Level 3 Leadership and Management Skills
GOV.UK: Growth and Skills Levy reforms factsheet (accessible version); Help to Grow: Management
Journal of Applied Psychology (via University of Central Florida STARS): Leadership training design, delivery, and implementation: A meta-analysis (Lacerenza et al., 2017)
Office for National Statistics: Management practices in the UK: 2016 to 2023
Quarterly Journal of Economics (via MIT DSpace): Promotions and the Peter Principle (Benson, Li and Shue, 2019)
Skills England: Team leader apprenticeship standard (ST0384); Operations manager apprenticeship standard (ST0385)
Last updated: 14 November 2026



