A new job management system is bought and the old spreadsheet stays open. An operations manager is appointed and every decision still goes to the owner. A change management framework is a structured model that sets out the stages or conditions needed to move a business from how it works now to a new way of working.
This guide explains six widely used change management models: Lewin’s unfreeze, change, refreeze; Kotter’s 8 steps; the Prosci ADKAR Model; the McKinsey 7-S framework; the Bridges Transition Model; and the Plan, Do, Check, Act cycle. It compares them in one table and shows how a business turning over £1M–£50M can pick one for a real change, such as a new system, a restructure or an owner stepping back.
What is a change management framework?
A change management framework gives managers a shared way to plan and lead a change: what happens first, who needs to be involved and what has to be true for the new way of working to hold. Frameworks differ in the level they work at, from the whole organisation to one person, and none guarantees success.
This guide covers the models themselves. How to run a change from start to finish, including the steps, how to tell whether a change has stuck and what guidance says about consulting employees, is covered in the guide to organisational change management.
What is Lewin’s change management model?
Lewin’s change management model describes change in three stages: unfreeze the current way of working, make the change, then refreeze so the new way becomes the norm. The model is widely attributed to the social psychologist Kurt Lewin, although researchers have questioned whether Lewin set it out in that form.
The three stages are unfreeze, change and refreeze:
- Unfreeze. Make the case that the current way of working has to change, so people are ready to let go of it.
- Change. Introduce the new process, structure or behaviour.
- Refreeze. Embed the new way, through procedures, measures and habits, so the business does not drift back.
A 2016 paper in the journal Human Relations by Stephen Cummings, Todd Bridgman and Kenneth Brown, Unfreezing change as three steps, compared what Lewin wrote with how later works present the model. The authors argue that Lewin never developed such a model and that it took form after his death. On that reading, the three stages are a later interpretation rather than Lewin’s own method, though they remain a simple way to explain change. Lewin’s work is also the starting point for organisational development, the wider discipline of improving how an organisation works through the involvement of its people.
In a business that changes year after year, a fixed ‘refreeze’ can sit awkwardly with ongoing improvement, so Lewin’s stages can be paired with a continuous improvement cycle such as PDCA.
What are Kotter’s 8 steps for leading change?
Kotter’s 8 steps are a sequence for leading change across an organisation, set out by John Kotter in his book Leading Change and now presented by his firm, Kotter Inc. The steps run from creating a sense of urgency to instituting change, with a guiding coalition, a vision and early wins in between.
As set out on the Kotter 8-Step Process page, the eight steps are now named:
- Create a sense of urgency. Help people see why the change matters now.
- Build a guiding coalition. Bring together a group with the credibility to lead it.
- Form a strategic vision. Describe what the business will look like after the change.
- Enlist a volunteer army. Draw in people who want to help make it happen.
- Enable action by removing barriers. Clear the processes, systems or habits that block the new way.
- Generate short-term wins. Show visible progress early.
- Sustain acceleration. Use that progress to keep going rather than declaring victory.
- Institute change. Build the new way into how the business runs.
The Kotter page describes the original model as linear and says it was later developed into the 8 Accelerators for Change, set out in the book Accelerate.
How does the Prosci ADKAR Model work?
The Prosci ADKAR Model works by breaking change down to the individual: a person needs Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability and Reinforcement to move to and stay in a new way of working. When a team stalls, ADKAR helps identify which of the five elements is missing for the people affected.
Prosci describes ADKAR as a model for individual change and states that it is not a complete change management methodology; it sits within the wider Prosci Methodology. The five elements are awareness, desire, knowledge, ability and reinforcement:
- Awareness. Understanding why the change is needed.
- Desire. Choosing to take part in and support the change.
- Knowledge. Knowing how to change and what success requires.
- Ability. Putting the new skills and behaviours into practice.
- Reinforcement. Sustaining the new way and preventing a slide back.
The gap between knowledge and ability is where day-to-day management matters. An engineer can attend training on a new mobile job form and still struggle with it on site in week two. Managers who ask what is getting in the way, rather than repeating the instruction, can help close that gap; how to build that habit is covered in how to create a coaching culture in a small organisation.
What does the McKinsey 7-S framework show about change?
The McKinsey 7-S framework shows that a change to one part of a business affects the others. The framework sets out seven interrelated elements, from strategy and structure to shared values and skills, and is used to check that a planned change does not fix one element while leaving the rest pulling the other way. The same idea of connected parts sits behind an operating model and its parts, from processes and organisation to information systems and the management system.
The framework came out of work at McKinsey & Company in the late 1970s. A McKinsey Quarterly article, Enduring ideas: The 7-S Framework (2008), says it was featured in Thomas Peters and Robert Waterman’s book In Search of Excellence, that it maps interrelated factors affecting an organisation’s ability to change, and that none of the factors ranks above the others. As the framework is usually presented, the seven elements are strategy, structure, systems, shared values, style, staff and skills:
- Strategy. The plan for where the business competes and how it wins work.
- Structure. Roles, reporting lines and decision rights, set through organisational design.
- Systems. The processes, procedures and software the work runs on.
- Shared values. The beliefs and culture that shape how people behave; how culture is built is covered in ways to create a healthy company culture.
- Style. How leaders and managers behave day to day.
- Staff. The people in the business and how they are recruited and developed.
- Skills. What the business as a whole is good at.
The 7-S framework is a diagnostic rather than a step-by-step plan. It shows a management team which other elements need to move with a change.
What is the Bridges Transition Model?
The Bridges Transition Model, developed by William Bridges, separates change, the external event, from transition, the inner psychological process people go through. The model describes three phases of transition, Endings, the Neutral Zone and New Beginnings, and is used to plan support for the people affected, not only the change itself.
William Bridges Associates describes the three phases as follows. Endings begin when people identify what they are losing and learn how to manage those losses. The Neutral Zone is the in-between period after the old way has ended and before the new one is fully working. New Beginnings are marked by a release of energy in a new direction.
The model is useful where a change takes something away from people: a familiar way of working, a role, status or a close working relationship with the owner. It explains why a change can be complete on paper while the team is still in the Neutral Zone.
How does the PDCA cycle work as a change model?
The PDCA cycle works as a change model by testing a change on a small scale before rolling it out: plan the change, do a small test, check the results and act on what was learned. The Plan, Do, Check, Act cycle then repeats, which suits repeated, smaller changes.
ASQ, the American Society for Quality, describes the plan-do-check-act cycle as a four-step model for carrying out change and lists the plan-do-study-act (PDSA) cycle, the Deming cycle and the Shewhart cycle as variations. ASQ lists implementing any change and working toward continuous improvement among the times to use it.
PDCA is used in continuous improvement and Lean, and it fits the short cycles of an agile operating model, where change is ongoing. For example, a new pricing sheet is trialled by one estimator for a month, quote turnaround is compared with the previous month, and the sheet is adjusted before every estimator uses it.
How do the main change management models compare?
The main change management models compare by the level they work at and the shape of change they assume. Kotter and Lewin describe a sequence for the whole organisation, ADKAR and Bridges focus on individuals, the 7-S framework maps connections, and PDCA treats change as repeated small tests.
| Model | Level | Shape of change | Most useful for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lewin (unfreeze, change, refreeze) | Organisation | Three stages | Explaining change simply | A fixed refreeze can sit awkwardly with ongoing improvement; origin disputed |
| Kotter’s 8 steps | Organisation | Sequence of eight steps | Leading a large, visible change | Original model described as linear |
| Prosci ADKAR | Individual | Five elements | Finding why a person or team is stuck | Not a complete methodology on its own |
| McKinsey 7-S | Organisation | Seven connected elements | Checking knock-on effects before a change | Diagnostic, not a plan |
| Bridges Transition Model | Individual and team | Three phases of transition | Changes involving loss of role or status | Says little about process or systems |
| PDCA cycle | Process or team | Repeating four-step cycle | Testing changes on a small scale | Needs a change that can be trialled on a small scale first |
The models are not exclusive: a business can combine an organisation-level model for the overall plan with an individual-level model for the people affected.
How does a growing business choose a change management framework?
A growing business chooses a change management framework by naming the change, identifying where it is most likely to stall, and picking the model best suited to that point. If the risk is the sequence, Kotter fits; individual adoption, ADKAR; knock-on effects, the 7-S framework; loss and uncertainty, Bridges; untested process changes, PDCA.
Rostone Operating Partners starts by writing the change down in one sentence and listing whose daily work it alters before any model is chosen; the model then follows from where the change is likely to get stuck. Three changes that heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC), electrical contracting and renewables businesses face show how the choice differs: a new job management system, a restructure and an owner stepping back.
Rostone looks at change through the four GRAX options: Grow, Raise, Acquire and Exit. Growth can bring new systems and management roles. Raising finance may mean showing a lender or investor that change is led and measured, and an acquisition needs a way to bring another business’s people and systems into the buyer’s own. For an exit, an owner stepping back is itself a change, and a buyer may look for evidence of it before a sale.
A new job management system
A new job management system changes how every job is booked, scheduled and closed. ADKAR suits the people side, because office staff and engineers each need awareness, desire, knowledge, ability and reinforcement before the new system becomes the normal way of working. PDCA suits the process side: trial the system on one team or job type, check what breaks and adjust before full rollout. Mapping and simplifying the process before configuring the software, as set out in business process improvement strategies, reduces the risk of building old workarounds into the new system.
A restructure
A restructure, such as creating a contracts manager or operations manager layer, changes structure first, and the 7-S framework helps check whether systems, style and skills will move with it. Kotter’s steps give the sequence for explaining and leading it. Where a restructure changes employees’ roles or terms, Acas sets out when consultation is legally required. The situations Acas lists include collective consultation with a recognised trade union or employee representatives where an employer proposes to dismiss and rehire, or make redundant, 20 or more employees at one establishment within 90 days or less, and consultation over employment contract changes in certain circumstances. Acas says an employer who is unsure could choose to consult anyway; consultation is covered in more detail in the guide to organisational change management.
An owner stepping back
An owner stepping back from daily decisions changes decision rights, relationships and, for long-serving staff, a familiar way of working. The Bridges Transition Model fits the people side, because the team and the owner both go through an ending. In Rostone’s work, the structure chart can change quickly while quotes, purchases and problems keep finding their way back to the owner, which is why the decision rules need writing down and testing, not only announcing. The longer-term planning side is covered in business succession planning.
What does the evidence say about change programmes failing?
The evidence for the claim that 70% of change programmes fail is weak. A 2011 review in the Journal of Change Management found no valid and reliable empirical evidence for a single 70% failure rate, so the figure is best treated as disputed rather than as an established fact.
In Do 70 per cent of all organizational change initiatives really fail? (Journal of Change Management, volume 11, issue 4, 2011), Mark Hughes of the University of Brighton critically reviewed five published sources that cite the 70% figure.
For a business, the more useful question is whether its own change is working: is the new way being used and has the old way gone?
What does UK guidance say about managing change at work?
UK guidance treats managing change as part of looking after people. The Health and Safety Executive includes change as one of six areas in its Management Standards for work-related stress, alongside demands, control, support, relationships and role, and describes the standards as a yardstick by which organisations can gauge their performance in tackling the key causes of stress.
The Health and Safety Executive’s Management Standards define the Change area as how organisational change, large or small, is managed and communicated in the organisation. The HSE notes that the six areas of work design, if not properly managed, are associated with poor health, lower productivity and increased accident and sickness absence rates. The HSE defines the Change area by how change is managed and communicated, so communication belongs inside whichever framework a business uses.
The business improvement service page explains how an operating partner works with owners of HVAC, electrical contracting and renewables businesses each month on margin, cash and capacity, including handing decisions to managers with clear limits and writing changes into the management system and playbook.
Frequently asked questions
In Prosci’s usage, a model such as ADKAR describes what a person needs in order to change, while a methodology connects the model with the processes and tools used to plan, manage and sustain organisational change. Not every writer draws the line in the same place, so it helps to check what each source means by the two terms.
Two of the simplest change management models are the three stages attributed to Lewin (unfreeze, change, refreeze) and the Plan, Do, Check, Act cycle. Lewin’s stages explain the overall shape of a change, while PDCA lets a small business test a change on one team or job type before rolling it out.
Kotter’s 8 steps set the overall sequence of a change, and ADKAR can then be applied to each group affected. If engineers understand why a new job form matters and want to use it but have not been trained on it, the missing element is knowledge, and that training gap becomes one of the barriers to clear under Kotter’s fifth step, enable action by removing barriers. Prosci describes ADKAR as a model for individual change, so it complements an organisation-level sequence rather than replacing it.
PDCA stands for Plan, Do, Check, Act, and PDSA for Plan, Do, Study, Act. ASQ describes the PDCA cycle as a four-step model for carrying out change and lists plan-do-study-act among its variations, alongside the Deming and Shewhart cycles. In ASQ’s description, the cycle plans a change, tests it on a small scale, reviews the results and acts on what was learned.
A project plan sets out tasks, dates and owners for delivering a change, such as installing a system or appointing a manager. A change management framework covers what people need to adopt the change and keep using it. A change can be delivered on time in the project plan and still not be adopted.
Sources
Acas: When consultation is required
ASQ (American Society for Quality): What is the plan-do-check-act (PDCA) cycle?
Health and Safety Executive: What are the Management Standards?
Kotter: The 8-Step Process for Leading Change
McKinsey & Company: Enduring ideas: The 7-S Framework (McKinsey Quarterly, 2008)
Prosci: The Prosci ADKAR Model
University of Brighton: Do 70 per cent of all organizational change initiatives really fail? (Hughes, 2011)
Victoria University of Wellington: Unfreezing change as three steps: Rethinking Kurt Lewin’s legacy for change management (Cummings, Bridgman and Brown, 2016)
William Bridges Associates: Bridges Transition Model
Last updated: 13 November 2026




