Two offers for a heating, electrical or renewables business can share a headline price and leave the owner with very different cash, control and risk. Investment deal structuring, or deal structuring, is deciding how money, ownership, risk and control are split between an owner and an investor or buyer, and when each payment is made.
This guide sets out seven principles for owners of businesses turning over £1M–£50M who are raising investment or selling, and explains how each works. It is general guidance, not legal, tax or financial advice.
What is investment deal structuring?
Investment deal structuring is the work of turning an agreed value into terms: the instrument, how much is paid at completion and later, who carries which risks, and what rights each party has afterwards. The same deal structure questions arise when raising capital or selling.
For an owner raising money, the structure decides what is given up; the options are covered in raising capital for a business. For a seller, it decides how much of the price is certain at completion.
What are the seven principles of deal structuring?
The seven principles of deal structuring are a checklist for reading any offer, from a minority investment to a full sale. Each covers one part of the deal structure that can change what an owner receives or carries at the same headline value.
The seven principles are the instrument, value and terms, ranking, deferred payments, the price mechanism, risk allocation and tax:
- Choose the instrument. Equity, debt or a mix sets who carries the risk.
- Separate value from terms. The terms decide what the headline valuation is worth.
- Know who is paid first. Share classes and liquidation preferences set the order of payment.
- Separate cash at completion from later money. Earn-outs, deferred consideration and loan notes delay part of the price.
- Agree how the final price is fixed. Completion accounts or a locked box settle cash, debt and working capital.
- Allocate risk explicitly. Warranties, indemnities and disclosure decide who pays if something is wrong.
- Understand the tax position early. Reliefs, rates and how a payment is classified affect what the owner keeps.
How do equity and debt differ in an investment deal?
Equity and debt differ in who carries the risk. Debt must be repaid with interest whatever the business’s results. With equity, the investor takes a share of the business, usually through new shares issued by the company, so the investor shares in profits and any sale value and usually has no fixed right to repayment.
The British Business Bank’s guide, everything you need to know about external finance, says debt finance means borrowing money from a lender who needs to be repaid, while equity finance means selling a share of the business.
A deal can combine the two. In a contracting business with stage payments and retentions, cash can vary sharply from month to month, so debt repayments are judged against the weaker months as well as the average.
In a management buyout, the buying team can fund the price with its own money, debt and deferred payments. An employee ownership trust can be funded from the company’s future profits.
What is the difference between valuation and deal terms?
Valuation is the headline figure placed on the business; deal terms are the conditions that decide how much of it the owner receives, when, and with what strings attached. Two offers at the same valuation can differ once timing, ranking, adjustments and protections are counted.
How buyers arrive at the headline number is covered in how buyers value an HVAC company and the guide to how to calculate a business valuation. The terms are usually first written down in a term sheet or heads of terms. The British Business Bank’s explainer, what is a term sheet?, describes it as typically a non-binding document outlining the basic terms of an investment. It notes that a confidentiality clause may be binding from the outset, and that an exclusivity (no-shop) clause can be legally enforceable if clearly worded. It lists five key components: valuation, equity stake, board structure and governance rights, liquidation preference and exit terms, and anti-dilution provisions, and notes that most no-shop periods last around 30 to 90 days. It describes anti-dilution provisions as protecting investors from dilution in future financing rounds.
Rostone Operating Partners reads an offer by setting the headline price beside the cash the owner would receive at completion, then listing the terms that move money between the two: deferred amounts, completion adjustments, retained sums and how each may be taxed.
How do preference shares and liquidation preferences work?
Preference shares work by carrying different rights from ordinary shares, such as a right to be paid before ordinary shareholders. A liquidation preference sets that order: it gives the investor priority to recover their investment on a sale or wind-up before the ordinary shareholders receive anything.
Section 629 of the Companies Act 2006 provides that shares are of one class if the rights attached to them are in all respects uniform. Companies use separate share classes, set out in their articles, to give different rights to dividends, votes and capital.
UK Private Capital, formerly the BVCA, publishes model documents for early stage investments for Series A rounds (not seed), with a February 2025 edition. In that set, the summary of terms records the agreed terms, including valuation and investor rights, and those rights are then written into the company’s articles of association and shareholders’ agreement. Earlier investor checks are covered in what makes a business investable.
How do earn-outs, deferred consideration and vendor loan notes work?
Earn-outs, deferred consideration and vendor loan notes all delay part of the sale price. Fixed deferred consideration is a set sum paid later; an earn-out is a form of deferred consideration that depends on the business’s performance after completion; a vendor loan note is a debt the buyer owes the seller and repays over time.
The ICAEW Corporate Finance Faculty’s Best-Practice Guideline 70, Earn-out Agreements (2023), describes earn-outs as a form of deferred consideration contingent on business performance or conditions within a specified period after completion. It links their use to a perception gap over value, lists measures such as revenue and EBITDA, and identifies ambiguous drafting of earn-out clauses as a frequent cause of disputes.
The three forms carry different risks for the seller:
- Fixed deferred consideration. The amount is set, but the seller relies on the buyer paying on the due date.
- Earn-out. The amount depends on results the seller may no longer control, measured under accounting rules the sale agreement needs to define.
- Vendor loan note. The seller is in effect lending part of the price to the buyer.
In Rostone’s work, a profit-based earn-out depends on job costing and management accounts both sides trust. Where labour, materials and variations are recorded inconsistently, the earn-out calculation can become the focus of a dispute, so the reporting is reviewed before an earn-out is agreed.
What is the difference between completion accounts and a locked box?
Completion accounts and a locked box are two ways of fixing the price for cash, debt and working capital. Completion accounts adjust it after the deal using a completion balance sheet; a locked box fixes it on an earlier balance sheet and bars value from passing to the seller or connected persons before completion, other than agreed permitted leakage. Both mechanisms rely on accounts the buyer can trust; how the finance function produces management accounts, job margins and work in progress figures is explained separately.
The ICAEW Corporate Finance Faculty’s Best-Practice Guideline 64, Completion Mechanisms (2024 edition), explains that free cash is normally added and debt deducted pound for pound, with an adjustment where working capital is not at a normal level. Under a locked box, economic risk transfers to the buyer at the locked box date, and any extraction of value by the seller or connected persons after that date, such as a dividend, is leakage unless agreed in advance as permitted leakage. The guideline also describes a value accrual, which compensates the seller for trading between the locked box date and completion, and notes that the seller will typically warrant the accuracy of the locked box accounts and that the buyer should carry out sufficient due diligence on that balance sheet. What makes up working capital in a contracting business, including retentions and unbilled work, is explained in the guide to cash flow management and working capital.
| Feature | Completion accounts | Locked box |
|---|---|---|
| Balance sheet used | Balance sheet at the completion date, drawn up after completion | Balance sheet at an agreed locked box date before completion |
| Price at signing | Estimate, then a true-up | Fixed, subject to leakage claims |
| When economic risk passes | At completion | At the locked box date |
| Main points of negotiation | Basis of preparation, individual balance sheet items and the normal level of working capital | Locked box date, leakage and permitted leakage, and any value accrual |
In a contracting business, work in progress, retentions and payments on account can move working capital sharply, so how normal working capital and debt are defined can move the price.
How do warranties and indemnities share risk between buyer and seller?
Warranties and indemnities share risk by setting out, in the sale or investment agreement, what the seller (or, in an investment, the company and its founders) confirms about the business and who pays if something proves wrong. A warranty is a contractual statement about the business; an indemnity is a promise to reimburse a specific liability if it arises.
The ICAEW Corporate Finance Faculty’s Best-Practice Guideline 71, Financial Due Diligence (2024), explains that due diligence can identify risks that may need additional protection through warranties and indemnities. It describes the disclosure letter as setting out information relating to the warranties and indemnities, so the buyer knows about those matters before signing.
For an owner, an issue found late in due diligence can come back as a price reduction, a retention or a specific indemnity, while an issue already documented can be disclosed against. What buyers check is covered in commercial due diligence for a contracting business. Preparing records in advance is covered in exit readiness. The investor’s side of these checks is set out on the operating partner for investors page.
How does tax affect the structure of a business sale?
Tax affects the structure of a business sale because the rate, relief and timing of the charge can depend on how each part of the price is paid. Cash at completion, an earn-out, a loan note and a payment linked to continued employment can each be treated differently.
These points summarise HMRC and GOV.UK guidance at the date of writing; they are not tax advice, and the rules change.
- Business Asset Disposal Relief. GOV.UK’s Business Asset Disposal Relief guidance gives a rate of 18% on gains on qualifying assets disposed of from 6 April 2026 (14% between 6 April 2025 and 5 April 2026). For shares, the conditions include being an employee or office holder of a trading company, and generally a holding of at least 5% of the shares and voting rights, with an entitlement to at least 5% of distributable profits and of assets on a winding up, or of the proceeds if the company is sold, all for at least two years before the sale. The how to claim page states a lifetime limit of £1 million.
- Proposed lower lifetime limit. An HMRC policy paper of 29 October 2026, Capital Gains Tax: new Business Asset Disposal Relief lifetime limit, proposes reducing the limit from £1 million to £500,000 for disposals on or after 6 April 2027, with anti-forestalling rules for unconditional contracts entered into before that date but not completed by it, unless the parties can show the contract was not entered into to gain a tax advantage from the timing rule (or, for connected parties, that it was entered into for wholly commercial reasons). It states that legislation will be introduced in the Finance Bill 2026.
- Proposed Founders’ Relief. A policy paper of 28 October 2026, Capital Gains Tax — introduction of a new founders relief, proposes a 10% rate on up to £10 million of lifetime gains for qualifying disposals from 6 April 2027. The paper describes it as aimed at individuals who played a significant role in founding a company. Proposed conditions include holding 25% of the ordinary share capital when the trade, or preparation for it, began; holding the shares for at least five tax years; five years’ UK residence; and a trading company with turnover of at least £10 million and at least 15 full-time equivalent employees that meets at least two of three growth tests. The paper says legislation will be introduced through amendments to the Finance Bill 2026, and a technical consultation on the design was launched on 28 October 2026.
- Earn-outs and deferred payments. HMRC’s Capital Gains Manual distinguishes deferred consideration that is ascertainable at the date of disposal (the full amount is included in the proceeds) from consideration that is unascertainable, such as an earn-out linked to future profits, where the seller receives a right to future payments.
- Earn-outs linked to employment. HMRC’s indicators for earn-outs as sale consideration (ERSM110940) include a sale agreement showing the earn-out is part of the price for the shares, and an earn-out value that reflects the value of the shares given up. Where the seller stays on as an employee, the indicators also include an earn-out that is not conditional on future employment beyond a reasonable requirement to stay to protect the value of the business being sold, and that contains no personal performance targets. Where an earn-out is partly consideration for the shares and partly a reward for services or an inducement to keep working, HMRC says its value is apportioned on a just and reasonable basis. ICAEW Guideline 70 notes that earn-outs may be treated as employment income in some circumstances.
- Loan notes that are qualifying corporate bonds. HMRC’s CG64161 explains that where shares are exchanged for loan notes that are qualifying corporate bonds, the gain is normally deferred until the notes are disposed of, when Business Asset Disposal Relief is unlikely still to be available. The seller can elect for the gain to be charged at the exchange so the relief can be claimed. How the loan notes are classified therefore affects the tax position.
How does deal structure change at each GRAX stage?
Deal structure changes at each GRAX stage because the owner is solving a different problem. Raising capital is about what is given up for the money; acquiring is about funding a purchase and managing risk; exiting is about how much of the price is certain at completion.
Rostone looks at deal structure through the four GRAX options: Grow, Raise, Acquire and Exit. At Grow, the records behind later warranties and earn-outs are built. At Raise, the questions are instrument, share class and investor rights. At Acquire, the owner is on the buying side of the same terms, including warranties, indemnities and the completion mechanism. At Exit, the focus is cash at completion against deferred amounts and protections.
The value and exit readiness service page sets out how HVAC, renewables and electrical contracting owners can reduce owner dependency, strengthen management routines and organise the records that support investment, succession or a potential sale.
Frequently asked questions
Deferred consideration is part of the sale price paid at a later date, and may be a fixed amount. An earn-out is a form of deferred consideration whose amount depends on the business’s performance after completion, measured against targets such as revenue or EBITDA, as described in ICAEW Guideline 70.
A liquidation preference is a term that gives an investor priority to recover their investment on a sale or wind-up before ordinary shareholders are paid. It attaches to a class of shares and is usually set out in the company’s articles of association, with related terms in the shareholders’ agreement. The British Business Bank lists it among the key terms in a term sheet.
A locked box deal fixes the price using a balance sheet drawn up at a date before completion. From that date, value must not leave the business to the seller or connected persons, except for permitted leakage agreed in advance. The economic risks and returns pass to the buyer at the locked box date.
A term sheet, or heads of terms, sets out the main terms of an investment or sale before the full legal documents are drafted. It is typically non-binding, although a confidentiality clause may be binding from the outset and an exclusivity (no-shop) clause can be legally enforceable if clearly worded. The British Business Bank lists valuation, equity stake, governance rights, liquidation preference and anti-dilution among its key components.
GOV.UK guidance gives a rate of 18% on gains on qualifying assets disposed of from 6 April 2026, with a lifetime limit of £1 million. An HMRC policy paper published in October 2026 proposes reducing the lifetime limit to £500,000 for disposals from 6 April 2027, subject to legislation.
Sources
British Business Bank: What is a term sheet?; Everything you need to know about external finance
GOV.UK: Business Asset Disposal Relief; Business Asset Disposal Relief: how to claim
HM Revenue & Customs: CG14881: Deferred consideration: what is ascertainable; CG14940: Deferred consideration: unascertainable deferred payments; CG64161: Business Asset Disposal Relief: share exchanges involving QCBs; ERSM110940: Securities options: earn-outs: key indicators of earn-out being sale consideration; Capital Gains Tax: new Business Asset Disposal Relief lifetime limit (29 October 2026); Capital Gains Tax — introduction of a new founders relief (28 October 2026)
ICAEW Corporate Finance Faculty: Completion Mechanisms, Best-Practice Guideline 64 (2024); Earn-out Agreements, Best-Practice Guideline 70 (2023); Financial Due Diligence, Best-Practice Guideline 71 (2024)
legislation.gov.uk: Companies Act 2006, section 629: Classes of shares
UK Private Capital (formerly BVCA): Model documents for early stage investments
Last updated: 13 November 2026




