A plan agreed in January, a spreadsheet of targets nobody opens after February, and a management meeting about last week’s problems rather than this quarter’s aims: goals can exist without steering anything. A goal setting framework is a structured method for choosing a small number of goals, writing them so progress can be measured, and reviewing them on a fixed rhythm.
This guide covers what goal-setting research shows, how SMART goals, OKRs, the BHAG and the balanced scorecard work, and how a contracting business can set and review goals without a planning team.
What is a goal setting framework?
A goal setting framework is an agreed way of deciding what a business is aiming for, how each goal is written, who owns it and when it is reviewed. Whichever framework is used, the aim is the same habit: goals that are specific, owned, measured and looked at regularly. The same habit applies to environmental targets; why set business sustainability goals sets out five reasons a contracting business might set them and how to keep them owned and reviewed.
Four questions help with any of the frameworks covered here: the aim, the measure, the owner and the review point.
- What is the business aiming for? A direction, written plainly enough that people can repeat it.
- How will progress show? A measure, with a starting point and a target.
- Who owns it? One named person for each goal.
- When is it reviewed? A set review point, from weekly check-ins to an annual review.
Goal setting overlaps with performance management and strategy execution. Goals say where the business is going; a performance management framework for a small business sets out the measures and review meetings that track progress; execution is the work of turning goals into results week by week. Planning in short cycles, with a review at the end of each, is part of an agile operating model in a contracting business.
What does goal-setting research say makes goals work?
Goal-setting research shows that specific, challenging goals lead to higher performance than vague goals or being told to “do your best”, and the effect is strongest when people are committed to the goals and get feedback on progress. The effect is weaker, and can reverse, on complex tasks where people are still learning how to do the work.
The main body of evidence comes from Edwin Locke and Gary Latham. Their 2002 review in American Psychologist, Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation, summarised 35 years of research and reported that “specific, difficult goals consistently led to higher performance than urging people to do their best”. The review describes four ways goals affect performance:
- Direction. Goals point attention and effort towards the work that matters to the goal.
- Energy. Higher goals lead to more effort than low goals.
- Persistence. Hard goals keep people working at a task for longer when they can control the time they spend on it.
- Strategy. Goals prompt people to find and use the knowledge and methods the task needs.
The same review sets out conditions that strengthen or weaken the effect. Goals work best when people are committed to them, and commitment is stronger when reaching the goal matters to people and when they believe they can reach it. Locke and Latham also state that people need summary feedback showing their progress against the goal.
The CIPD, the UK professional body for HR and people development, published a December 2016 research report, Could do better? Assessing what works in performance management, which reviewed the highest-quality studies on goal setting and appraisal. It found that “specific and challenging goals work well for relatively straightforward tasks” but not for complex tasks that involve interrelated steps or learning new skills, and that feedback is crucial for goal setting to be effective. For complex work, the report points instead to goals focused on learning and behaviour.
For a contracting business, the difference is practical. A target for days from completion to invoice suits a clear, repeatable process. A new service line, such as heat pump installation, may suit learning goals at first (training completed, first designs reviewed, a pricing model tested) before a revenue target.
Which goal setting framework fits which job?
Goal setting frameworks differ in purpose and time horizon. SMART checks how a single goal is written, OKRs suit a short cycle such as a quarter, MBO agrees individual objectives between a manager and an employee, a balanced scorecard sets measures across the business, and a BHAG gives a direction over many years.
Four frameworks are covered in detail (SMART goals, OKRs, the BHAG and the balanced scorecard), with management by objectives explained as the forerunner of OKRs.
| Framework | Time horizon | Main purpose | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| SMART | Any | Checks how one goal is written | Does not say which goals matter |
| OKRs | A short cycle, such as a quarter | Links an objective to measurable results | Key results written as tasks |
| MBO | A set period, such as a year | Agrees individual objectives with a manager | Becomes a once-a-year form |
| Balanced scorecard | Ongoing, often set yearly | Balances financial and operational measures | Too many measures |
| BHAG | Many years | Sets a long-term direction | No link to this year’s goals |
Goal setting frameworks sit alongside improvement frameworks such as Lean and PDCA, which deal with how the work itself is changed; the differences are set out in what a business improvement framework is and how the approaches compare.
How do SMART goals work?
SMART goals work by testing each goal against five criteria: specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound. A goal that passes all five is clear enough for the person who owns it, and for anyone else, to tell whether it has been met, and by when.
Acas guidance on reviews and appraisals sets out the five criteria for SMART objectives:
- Specific. Clear about what the employee will actually do.
- Measurable. So it is possible to know whether it has been achieved.
- Achievable. Realistic.
- Relevant. To the employee’s job and responsibilities.
- Time-bound. With a reasonable time frame for achieving it.
The words behind the letters vary between sources. The CIPD report notes that SMART is often used by practitioners, while the research itself mainly tests how specific and how challenging goals are.
A contracting example (figures illustrative): “Reduce average days from job completion to invoice from nine to three by 31 March, with the office manager as owner and a progress check at each weekly meeting.” The goal names the measure, the starting point, the target, the date and the owner.
How do OKRs work?
OKRs (Objectives and Key Results) work by pairing one qualitative objective, which says what is to be achieved, with a small number of measurable key results that show whether it has been achieved. They are set for a fixed period, such as a quarter, and reviewed during and at the end of it.
What Matters, the organisation co-founded by John Doerr, describes OKRs as “a collaborative goal-setting methodology” and says they are typically written with an objective at the top and three to five key results below it. It describes an objective as “simply what is to be achieved”, and says effective key results are “specific, time-bound, and aggressive yet realistic”.
According to the same source, Andy Grove created the method at Intel, building on management by objectives (MBO), the approach associated with Peter Drucker; John Doerr later introduced it to Google’s founders in 1999. What Matters notes that, unlike MBOs, OKRs are kept separate from pay.
A contracting example (figures illustrative) of one OKR for a quarter:
- Objective. Get paid faster for finished work.
- Key result one. Average days from completion to invoice down from nine to three.
- Key result two. Job sheets complete on the day for at least 95% of jobs.
- Key result three. Debtor days down from 58 to 45.
The key results describe outcomes, not tasks. “Buy a new job management app” is a task; buying it does not show that cash is coming in faster.
What is a BHAG and when does it fit?
A BHAG, short for Big Hairy Audacious Goal, is a bold, long-term goal meant to unite a business around one clear aim. A BHAG fits the top of a goal structure, as the direction that yearly and quarterly goals work towards, rather than as a target to review each month.
Jim Collins describes the BHAG as “a powerful way to stimulate progress”, a concept developed in the book Built to Last. His examples include NASA’s moon mission in the 1960s. A good BHAG, on his account, has a clear finish line and needs little explanation.
For a contracting business, a BHAG might be maintaining 1,000 commercial heat pump systems across its region within ten years (figure illustrative). Its value lies in how it shapes nearer-term choices: which services to grow, who to hire and which systems to build. A BHAG is a goal rather than a purpose; how a purpose-driven business uses a purpose beyond profit covers the difference and what the research shows.
How does the balanced scorecard set goals across a business?
The balanced scorecard sets goals across a business by choosing measures from four perspectives (financial, customer, internal processes, and innovation and learning) so that financial targets are balanced by the operational measures that drive them. It is meant to stop a business setting only sales and profit goals.
Robert Kaplan and David Norton introduced the idea in the January–February 1992 issue of Harvard Business Review, in The Balanced Scorecard: Measures that Drive Performance. Its summary opens with “What you measure is what you get” and argues that traditional financial measures such as return on investment and earnings per share can give misleading signals for continuous improvement and innovation. The University of Cambridge Institute for Manufacturing summarises the four perspectives as four questions, shown here with contracting examples:
| Perspective | Question | Contracting example measures |
|---|---|---|
| Financial | “How do we look to shareholders?” | Gross margin by job type; debtor days |
| Customer | “How do customers see us?” | First-time fix rate; complaints; repeat customers |
| Internal | “What must we excel at?” | Quote turnaround; days from completion to invoice |
| Innovation and learning | “Can we continue to improve and create value?” | Engineers trained in new technologies; improvements adopted |
The scorecard is one part of a wider management cycle. How targets, measures, reviews and actions connect across a whole business is explained in the guide to business performance management.
How does a contracting business set and review goals?
A contracting business can set and review goals by linking a long-term direction to a few yearly goals, breaking those into quarterly objectives with named owners, and checking progress at a weekly management meeting. Putting goals on the agenda of a meeting that already happens is one way to keep them in view without adding another meeting.
One simple goal cycle has five steps: set the direction, choose the year’s goals, set quarterly objectives, review weekly and reset each quarter.
- Set the direction. Write down what the business aims to become over three to ten years.
- Choose the year’s goals. Pick three to five goals, ideally spread across finance, customers, processes and people, each with a measure and a starting point.
- Set quarterly objectives. Break each yearly goal into an objective and three to five measurable key results for the next quarter, each with one owner.
- Review weekly. Spend ten to fifteen minutes of the weekly management meeting on the measures; agree actions where one is off track.
- Reset each quarter. Score the quarter, record what was learned and set the next objectives.
In Rostone Operating Partners’ work with contracting businesses, the goals that last are tied to a number the business already records, such as days to invoice or first-time fix rate, and owned by someone who can change the work behind it. A quick check Rostone uses: can the owner of each goal say the measure, the target, the date and when it is next reviewed, without looking it up?
The people doing the work can help show which goals are realistic. Leadership behaviours that support business performance, such as giving feedback on the work and holding people to account with a named owner and a short weekly review of results, help keep a goal cycle going between reviews. Once goals are set, the separate work of improving business strategy execution turns them into results.
Why does goal setting matter for productivity?
Goal setting is linked to productivity through management practice: the Office for National Statistics (ONS) counts how targets are set, tracked and reviewed as one of four parts of its management practices score, and reports that management practices are associated with higher productivity.
The ONS bulletin Management practices in the UK: 2016 to 2023 builds its management score from four dimensions: continuous improvement, key performance indicators, targets (“how targets are set, tracked and reviewed”) and employment practices. The survey covers production and services firms with 10 or more employees. In 2023 the average score was 0.55 on a 0 to 1 scale, up from 0.49 in 2020, and scores rose with firm size, from 0.51 for firms with 10 to 19 employees to 0.68 for firms with more than 250 (2023 figures cover the UK; earlier years cover Great Britain).
The ONS figures show management scores and productivity moving together: in the bulletin’s analysis, a 1% increase in a firm’s labour productivity is correlated with a 0.02 increase in its management score. The figures cover the whole management score, not target setting alone, and do not on their own show that better target setting causes higher productivity.
Rostone looks at goal setting through the four GRAX options: Grow, Raise, Acquire and Exit. To grow, goals focus the team on the few changes that free capacity, such as faster invoicing. To raise finance, a record of goals set and met can show a lender how the business is managed. To acquire, shared goals give two businesses one set of measures. To exit, goals owned by a management team help show a buyer that performance does not rest on the founder. How these changes show up in a valuation is covered in operational improvements that increase business valuation.
What goes wrong with goal setting?
Goal setting goes wrong when there are too many goals, when goals describe tasks rather than outcomes, when nobody reviews progress, when the type of goal does not suit the task, or when very high targets are tied to pay. Three of these draw directly on goal-setting research: feedback on progress, matching the type of goal to the task, and the risks of very high goals tied to incentives.
Five problems can undermine goal setting: too many goals, tasks instead of outcomes, no feedback, the wrong kind of goal for complex work, and very high goals tied to incentives.
- Too many goals. Long lists of priorities can spread effort thin; a short list is easier to keep in view.
- Tasks instead of outcomes. “Launch a new website” is a task; “more qualified enquiries” is an outcome.
- No feedback. Goals set in January and checked in December leave no chance to adjust; both Locke and Latham and the CIPD stress feedback on progress.
- The wrong kind of goal for complex work. The CIPD report notes that on complex tasks, specific challenging goals can focus people on the consequences of failure; for a new service, learning goals may suit the early stages better.
- Very high goals tied to incentives. The CIPD report notes research linking the overuse of very high goals combined with financial incentives to unethical behaviour (the effects found were small, and especially likely when people fell just short of the goal).
Goal setting is also a part of growing without the business getting harder to run, which is covered in business scaling strategies for a growing business.
The Business Improvement service works inside a contracting business through Diagnose, Design and Deliver, including a ranked plan the leadership team owns and a weekly rhythm of meetings and numbers that runs without the owner.
Frequently asked questions
A key performance indicator (KPI) is a measure a business tracks continuously, such as first-time fix rate or debtor days. A key result is a measurable outcome tied to one objective for a set period, such as a quarter. A KPI can become a key result when the business sets out to move it by a set amount within that period.
An OKR cycle is the repeating rhythm in which OKRs are written, agreed, tracked and scored. What Matters, the organisation co-founded by John Doerr, describes five phases: crafting, sharing, locking, tracking, and grading and reflecting. It suggests introducing new OKRs at least a couple of times a year.
Management by objectives (MBO) is an approach in which a manager and an employee agree individual objectives and later review results against them. OKRs grew out of MBO at Intel, with a shorter cycle and measurable key results under each objective.
Business goals can be reviewed at several rhythms, such as measures weekly, objectives quarterly and the overall direction yearly. For individual employees, Acas guidance suggests formal performance reviews at least once a year, with regular check-ins between them.
A stretch goal is a goal set deliberately beyond what the business expects to reach easily. What Matters says aspirational OKRs are sometimes called stretch goals, or “moonshots”.
Sources
American Psychologist: Locke and Latham (2002), Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation: A 35-year odyssey
CIPD: Performance management: Could do better?; Could do better? Assessing what works in performance management (2016 report)
Acas: Reviews and appraisals
What Matters: What is an OKR? Definition and examples; The OKR cycle
Jim Collins: BHAG
Harvard Business Review: The Balanced Scorecard: Measures that Drive Performance (1992)
University of Cambridge Institute for Manufacturing: Balanced Scorecard
Office for National Statistics: Management practices in the UK: 2016 to 2023
Last updated: 13 November 2026




